U.S. Lowers Standards in Army Recruiting Crisis

U.S. Lowers Standards in Army Recruiting Crisis

The US military has stopped battalion commanders from dismissing new recruits for drug abuse, alcohol, poor fitness and pregnancy in an attempt to halt the rising attrition rate in an army under growing strain as a result of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

An internal memo sent to senior commanders said the growing dropout rate was “a matter of great concern” in an army at war. It told officers: “We need your concerted effort to reverse the negative trend. By reducing attrition 1{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d}, we can save up to 3,000 initial-term soldiers. That’s 3,000 more soldiers in our formations.”

Officially, the memo, reported in the Wall Street Journal and posted on www.Slate.com, ordered battalion commanders to refer cases of problem soldiers up to brigade level. Military experts warned that the move would make it more difficult to remove poor soldiers and would lower quality in the ranks.

A military spokesman told the Guardian yesterday: “It was merely a question of an additional set of eyes looking at an issue before we release potential recruits.”

The Wall Street Journal quoted a battalion commander as saying: “It is the guys on weight control … school no-shows, drug users, etc, who eat up my time and cause my hair to grey prematurely … Often they have more than one of these issues simultaneously.”

Asked what the new policy meant, John Pike from the thinktank Globalsecurity.orgsaid: “It means there is a war on. They need all the soldiers they can get. But it is a dilemma. You need good soldiers more in wartime than peacetime.”

The latest controversy comes amid a growing recruitment and retention crisis in the US military. Last month the army announced that it was 6,659 soldiers short of its recruitment targets for the year so far. On Wednesday, the department of defence withheld the latest figures, a move seen by most commentators as heralding more bad news.

The military’s target is 80,000 new recruits this year, but the army only managed 73{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} of its target in February, 68{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} in March and 57{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} in April, forcing the expansion of a pilot programme offering 15-month active duty enlistments, rather than the usual four years.

The crisis has even led to fears – despite repeated denials by President George Bush – of a return to the draft system that conscripted 1.8 million Americans during the Vietnam war.

Major General Michael Rochelle, the head of army recruitment, said this was the “toughest recruiting climate ever faced by the all-volunteer army”, with the war raising concern among potential recruits and their families.

“Recruiters have been given greater leeway,” said Mr Pike. “By doing things to increase quantity you are also doing things to decrease quality, but they have made the judgment that that is the way to go.”

One recruiting standard that was about to be lowered was a rule governing tattoos in the navy and marines. “If you have excessively prominent and vulgar tattoos they will not take you right now, but that is about to change,” he said.

A commander quoted in the Wall Street Journal linked the growing attrition rate among new recruits to a slipping of standards by recruiters, who were under pressure to meet their monthly quotas.

An army spokeswoman said: “We are doing our best to decrease attrition level, but we have not and will not lower our standards for recruiting and retaining soldiers.”

Yet in March 17.4{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} of all new army recruits failed to complete training, while another 7.3{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} did not finish the first three years with their unit.

Last month it emerged that one recruiter gave advice on how to cheat a mandatory drug test to a potential would-be soldier who said he had a drug problem.

In another incident in Texas, a recruiter threatened a 20-year-old man with arrest if he did not turn up to an interview. As a result all military recruiters stopped work for one day to attend retraining classes on acceptable practices.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on U.S. Lowers Standards in Army Recruiting Crisis

Growing Problem for Military Recruiters: Parents

Growing Problem for Military Recruiters: Parents

Rachel Rogers, a single mother of four in upstate New York, did not worry about the presence of National Guard recruiters at her son’s high school until she learned that they taught students how to throw hand grenades, using baseballs as stand-ins. For the last month she has been insisting that administrators limit recruiters’ access to children.

Orlando Terrazas, a former truck driver in Southern California, said he was struck when his son told him that recruiters were promising students jobs as musicians. Mr. Terrazas has been trying since September to hang posters at his son’s public school to counter the military’s message.

Meanwhile, Amy Hagopian, co-chairwoman of the Parent-Teacher-Student Association at Garfield High School in Seattle, has been fighting against a four-year-old federal law that requires public schools to give military recruiters the same access to students as college recruiters get, or lose federal funding. She also recently took a few hours off work to stand beside recruiters at Garfield High and display pictures of injured American soldiers from Iraq.

“We want to show the military that they are not welcome by the P.T.S.A. in this building,” she said. “We hope other P.T.S.A.’s will follow.”

Two years into the war in Iraq, as the Army and Marines struggle to refill their ranks, parents have become boulders of opposition that recruiters cannot move.

Mothers and fathers around the country said they were terrified that their children would have to be killed – or kill – in a war that many see as unnecessary and without end.

Around the dinner table, many parents said, they are discouraging their children from serving.

At schools, they are insisting that recruiters be kept away, incensed at the access that they have to adolescents easily dazzled by incentive packages and flashy equipment.

A Department of Defense survey last November, the latest, shows that only 25 percent of parents would recommend military service to their children, down from 42 percent in August 2003.

“Parents,” said one recruiter in Ohio who insisted on anonymity because the Army ordered all recruiters not to talk to reporters, “are the biggest hurdle we face.”

Legally, there is little a parent can do to prevent a child over 18 from enlisting. But in interviews, recruiters said that it was very hard to sign up a young man or woman over the strong objections of a parent.

The Pentagon – faced with using only volunteers during a sustained conflict, an effort rarely tried in American history – is especially vexed by a generation of more activist parents who have no qualms about projecting their own views onto their children.

Lawrence S. Wittner, a military historian at the State University of New York, Albany, said today’s parents also had more power.

“With the draft, there were limited opportunities for avoiding the military, and parents were trapped, reduced to draft counseling or taking their children to Canada,” he said. “But with the volunteer armed force, what one gets is more vigorous recruitment and more opportunities to resist.”

Some of that opportunity was provoked by the very law that was supposed to make it easier for recruiters to reach students more directly. No Child Left Behind, which was passed by Congress in 2001, requires schools to turn over students’ home phone numbers and addresses unless parents opt out. That is often the spark that ignites parental resistance.

Recruiters, in interviews over the past six months, said that opposition can be fierce. Three years ago, perhaps 1 or 2 of 10 parents would hang up immediately on a cold call to a potential recruit’s home, said a recruiter in New York who, like most others interviewed, insisted on anonymity to protect his career. “Now,” he said, “in the past year or two, people hang up all the time. “

Several recruiters said they had even been threatened with violence.

“I had one father say if he saw me on his doorstep I better have some protection on me,” said a recruiter in Ohio. “We see a lot of hostility.”

Military officials are clearly concerned. In an interview last month, Maj. Gen. Michael D. Rochelle, commander of Army recruiting, said parental resistance could put the all-volunteer force in jeopardy. When parents and other influential adults dissuade young people from enlisting, he said, “it begs the question of what our national staying power might be for what certainly appears to be a long fight.”

In response, the Army has rolled out a campaign aimed at parents, with television ads and a Web site that includes videos of parents talking about why they supported their children’s decision to enlist. General Rochelle said that it was still too early to tell if it is making a difference.

But Col. David Slotwinski, a former chief of staff for Army recruiting, said that the Army faced an uphill battle because many baby boomer parents are inclined to view military service negatively, especially during a controversial war.

“They don’t realize that they have a role in helping make the all-volunteer force successful,” said Colonel Slotwinski, who retired in 2004. “If you don’t, you’re faced with the alternative, and the alternative is what they were opposed to the most, mandatory service.”

Many of the mothers and fathers most adamant about recruitment do have a history of opposition to Vietnam. Amy Hagopian, 49, a professor of public health at the University of Washington, and her husband, Stephen Ludwig, 57, a carpenter, said that they and many parents who contest recruiting at Garfield High in Seattle have a history of antiwar sentiment and see their efforts as an extension of their pacifism.

But, he added, parents are also reacting to what they see as the military’s increased intrusion into the lives of their children.

“The recruiters are in your face, in the library, in the lunchroom,” he said. “They’re contacting the most vulnerable students and recruiting them to go to war.”

The access is legally protected. As recently as 2000, said one former recruiter in California, it was necessary to dig through the trash at high schools and colleges to find students’ names and phone numbers. But No Child Left Behind mandates that school districts can receive federal funds only if they grant military recruiters “the same access to secondary school students” as is provided to colleges and employers.

So although the Garfield P.T.S.A. voted last month to ban military recruiters from the school and its 1,600 students, the Seattle school district could not sign on to the idea without losing at least $15 million in federal education funds.

“The parents have chosen to take a stand, but we still have to comply with No Child Left Behind,” said Peter Daniels, communications director for the district. In Whittier, a city of 85,000 10 miles southeast of East Los Angeles, about a dozen families last September accused the district of failing to properly advise parents that they had the right to deny recruiters access to their children’s personal information.

Mr. Terrazas, 51, the father of a Whittier High School junior, said the notification was buried among other documents in a preregistration packet sent out last summer.

“It didn’t say that the military has access to students’ information,” he said. “It just said to write a letter if you didn’t want your kid listed in a public directory.”

A few years ago, after Sept. 11, the issue might not have gotten Mr. Terrazas’s attention. His father served in World War II, his brother in Vietnam, and he said that he had always supported having a strong military able to defend the country.

But after the war in Iraq yielded no weapons of mass destruction, and as the death toll has mounted, he cannot reconcile the pride he feels at seeing marines deliver aid after the tsunami in Asia with his concern over the effort in Baghdad, he said.

“Because of the situation we’re in now, I would not want my son to serve,” he said. “It’s the policy that I’m against, not the military.”

After Mr. Terrazas and several other parents expressed their concern about the school’s role in recruitment, the district drafted a new policy. On May 23, it introduced a proposed opt-out form for the district’s 14,000 students.

The form, said Ron Carruth, Whittier’s assistant superintendent, includes an explanation of the law, and boxes that parents can check to indicate they do not want information on their child released to either the military, colleges, vocational schools or other sources of recruitment. Mr. Carruth said that next year the district would also prohibit all recruiters from appearing in classrooms, and keep the military ones from bringing equipment like Humvees onto school grounds, a commonly used recruitment tool.

He said that some of the information from the 11-by-17-inch poster that Mr. Terrazas sought to post, including how to verify recruiters’ claims about financial benefits, will be part of a pamphlet created by the school for students.

And at least a dozen other districts in the area, Mr. Carruth added, up from three in November, are considering similar plans.

Unlike Mr. Terrazas, Ms. Rogers, 37, of High Falls in the upper Hudson Valley, had not thought much about the war before she began speaking out in her school district. She had been “politically apathetic,” she said. She did not know about No Child Left Behind’s reporting requirements, nor did she opt out.

When her son, Jonah, said he was thinking of sitting out a gym class that was to be led by National Guard recruiters, Ms. Rogers, who works part time as a clerk at the local motor vehicles office and receives public assistance, said she told him not to be “a rebel without a cause.”

“In this world,” she recalled telling him, “we need a strong military.”

But then she heard from her son that the class was mandatory, and that recruiters were handing out free T-shirts and key chains – “Like, ‘Hey, let’s join the military. It’s fun,’ ” she said.

First she called the Rondout Valley High School to complain about the “false advertising,” she said, then her congressman.

On May 24, at the first school board meeting since the gym class, she read aloud from a recruiting handbook that advised recruiters on ways to gain maximum access to schools, including offering doughnuts. A high school senior, Katie Coalla, 18, stood up at one point and tearfully defended the recruiters, receiving applause from the crowd of about 70, but Ms. Rogers persisted.

“Pulling in this need for heartstrings patriotic support is clouding the issue,” she said. “The point is not whether I support the troops. It’s about whether a well-organized propaganda machine should be targeted at children and enforced by the schools.”

Laura Cummins, in Accord, N.Y., contributed reporting for this article.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Growing Problem for Military Recruiters: Parents

Finding The Way Home

Mayor Paul Bunn paces the parking lot in front of Bradford’s city hall, barking out orders on his cell phone while smoking a cigarette. The puffing and the posturing are habits honed by a year of leading troops through hellfire in Baghdad. “People do what I say, when I say, how I say, and no questions asked,” says Bunn in his staff-sergeant mode, stubbing out the cigarette. The city staff—all two of them—ruin the effect, however, by peering out a city-hall window and smiling indulgently at the boss. It is his first day back at work. They’re just glad to have him back in one piece.

A year and a half ago, the mayor, the police chief and eight other men from this Arkansas town of 819, an hour’s drive north of Little Rock, were called up for duty in Iraq by the Arkansas National Guard; one more was called by the Air Force Reserve. It was a blow not just to the weekend warriors—who were more accustomed to tornado cleanup than fighting—but to their families and Bradford’s civic life as well. The town’s big projects—to update the water system, jail the local methamphetamine dealers and make a clean sweep of the junk in people’s yards—slowly stalled. Given fears for the town’s soldiers, it was as if Bradford held its breath for the year they were in combat, hanging on every newscast, every e-mail and call home. “Nothing progressed,” says Farrah Chambliss, 28, wife of police chief Josh Chambliss, also a staff sergeant in Iraq. “We … just floated.”

The “Gunslingers” of Arkansas’ 39th Infantry Brigade are home now. All the Guardsmen from Bradford survived, their lives and limbs intact after a year of hunting insurgents on the streets of Baghdad’s scariest neighborhoods, like Sadr City and Adhamiyah. Wherever you go in Bradford these days—down to McCall’s Family Restaurant for lunch or up to Edens Quick Check for some gossip—faces light up as the mayor and the police chief turn up, making their daily rounds. But like the estimated 226,000 other weekend soldiers who have returned from service abroad since the 9/11 attacks, Bradford’s men came home to new and jumbled emotions as well as huge celebrations. The mayor, his own business near bankruptcy because of his absence, is edgy and angry. The police chief, his hands noticeably shaky, fears he is quicker on the draw. Their wives, relieved, bemused and touched, notice that their men hug more. But it’s not just their families the men are holding close. It’s also their fears. Here’s how two men and a town are finding their way home, tentatively, from the horrors of Iraq.

The Police Chief

What can you say about a man who shows you a picture of a human heart lying on the road after a bombing in Baghdad, then turns to his whiny 9-month-old daughter and calms her with a gentle “Hey, Toots”? Bradford’s boyish police chief, Josh Chambliss, 30, is sitting in his neat-as-a-pin living room with wife Farrah and baby Chloe, clicking through an electronic album on his computer of photos he took of life in Baghdad: the palace of Saddam Hussein’s son Uday and his infamous rape bed. Bloody, blown-up bodies on a street, a severed head, the heart blasted from an Iraqi’s chest lying in the street. “It freaks Farrah out,” Chambliss says with an apologetic look her way. He’s not quite sure why he keeps those pictures or why he keeps looking at them.

Chambliss signed up for the National Guard at age 17 when he was still at Bradford High. He recently re-enlisted for another six years despite narrowly escaping a roadside bomb attack in Iraq just two months before coming home. “I would do it over again if I had to. It’s my job,” he says. Still, he’s more cynical about the mission. “In my first six months, I went from being scared to excited, to ‘Hey, this is kind of fun’ and feeling sorry for the Iraqis,” he says. Then, as attacks on U.S. troops mounted despite American efforts to help the Iraqis rebuild, Chambliss just wanted to get the job done and come home. “Finally,” he says, “it was sheer hatred of the Iraqi people. People would say that is racist, but it’s not. It was a culture clash. We didn’t understand each other.”

Back on the job in Bradford, Chambliss says he notices a change in himself. Driving through town in his police cruiser, he describes the arrest a day earlier of a suspected meth dealer. “I knocked on the front door and got him coming out the back, but I realized I had my hand on my gun and was fixin’ to draw down on him,” says Chambliss. His deputy stopped him, but his eagerness to pull a gun shook him. It still does.

Turning his cruiser into Perry Turner’s tractor shop, Chambliss shifts gears and shares his dreams for Bradford, of the town’s becoming a draw for the weekend arts-and-crafts crowd, its streets lined with majestic Bradford pear trees. But the $500,000 annual town budget and a 50-year-old water system are holding back development. Bradford’s patrol cars have 35-year-old radars, and Chambliss came home from Iraq to find a mere $820 in the department kitty for new purchases. “I’m not going to talk down the war,” says the police chief, a staunch Republican, “but I don’t understand why we’re spending all this money there when we’re having trouble here.” His idea is to raise $10,000 for new police equipment by holding a tractor pull. The last one drew spectators from seven states.

The Mayor

At 37, Paul Bunn is an old hand at combat, an infantryman who served in Panama and the first Gulf War. This latest experience was the worst. His unit in Baghdad, part of the military’s quick-reaction force, which deployed for four-day stretches against insurgents, was hit by 37 improvised explosive devices while in Iraq, 13 in one day in Sadr City. Bunn still has nightmares about a rocket attack on his unit in April 2004. He spent two hours, he says, picking up “pieces and pieces and pieces” of bodies of U.S. soldiers. He remains agitated about the way the military treated the 56 Iraqi translators who worked closely with him on rebuilding projects near the end of his tour; they weren’t allowed to use cafeteria facilities with American soldiers, he says. Four were taken and executed by insurgents, one on Bunn’s last day in Iraq. “I thought I was prepared for anything,” he says, “because it wasn’t my first war.”

The mayor, who grew up one of 14 kids in the nearby city of Searcy, is taking the failure of his insulation business in Little Rock hard as well. “It’s so embarrassing. When I left, it was netting about $300,000 a year, and now it’s $500,000 in the hole,” he says. The tension is exacting a toll. “There’s a disconnect there somewhere,” Bunn says, tapping his head. “My highs are real high and my lows are real low. It’s like a light switch, my mind.” Hoping that other soldiers will seek help, he’s open about taking Paxil, an antidepressant, for posttraumatic stress disorder. Loud noises—even test runs of the town’s tornado siren—unnerve him. He has deactivated all the alarms in his home and even the seat-belt warnings in his cars. “Get into my car and there’s no ding-ding,” he says.

When he left for the war, Bunn gave an enthusiastic speech to Bradford’s sixth-graders about the duty of “citizen soldiers” to help Iraq’s “nation building.” No one realized how much the mayor had changed until April, when several hundred people gathered downtown to dedicate a patriotic wall, dreamed up by the soldiers’ wives and families to honor all the townsfolk who had served in battle from World War I to Afghanistan and Iraq. The list started with 25 names and grew to 400. Bunn, not yet officially released from active duty but out on a pass from Fort Sill that weekend, gave a graphic speech on the horrors of duty in Iraq and his struggle to survive, then launched into a tirade about the waste of U.S. resources he saw up close. “Let’s trust the President—about as far as we can throw him,” he said bitterly.

His outburst was the talk of the town for days afterward. Some thought he had gone too far on the politics and gore, though even some of the town’s most conservative citizens were sympathetic. “Coming back from a place like that, everybody understands,” says Tim Clark, music and outreach minister at the mayor’s church, Bradford Baptist. Citizens State Bank officer Carol Cagle, whose grandson Richard Farmer served with Bunn in Iraq, says she had “mixed emotions” about the mayor’s speech. “He was emotional, but Richard is having problems too,” she says, reluctant to share more with an outsider.

“I probably said some things I shouldn’t have,” Bunn says now. He blames his off-kilter speech on a second drug he’s taking for his posttraumatic stress disorder, which, he says with a laugh, makes him “a slobbering idiot.” Says Bunn: “There was no more hard-core Republican than me until I went to Iraq. I’m against abortion and gay rights, and don’t mess with my guns, but I have grown up a lot. When you have spent a year in hell and you have seen the waste of money I have seen …” He lets the thought hang. Bottom line: “I’m neither party now.”

Sitting in his office at city hall, his desk still bare, the mayor surveys a list of priorities. No. 1: the town’s water system. The water, though drinkable, is often discolored because of iron content. Bunn thought he had set repairs in motion when he left, but he came home to find that not a spade of dirt had been turned. While he fumes over the delays caused partly by the city council’s hesitancy to start big projects with him gone, he’s really incensed that Bradford finds itself in financial straits while Washington invests billions in Iraq. “What I don’t understand is how we can rebuild everything we are rebuilding over there, but here in America our infrastructure is falling apart,” he says. “I had to borrow $776,000 for this city for water. They are spending it just like nothing over there. That’s reckless, and that’s wrong. As soon as we build something, they blow it up. That’s a big problem with me, big problem.”

The Town

When Bradford was left with no mayor after the Gunslingers deployed, Greba June Edens—Ms. Greba to everyone in town—stepped into the job. She was 78. It was the third time in 21 years she had had to fill in as mayor, part of her duty as the town’s recorder and treasurer; one previous mayor resigned and another pleaded guilty to possessing marijuana with the intent to distribute it. A grade-school teacher in Bradford for 35 years, Edens had a reputation for being a terror in the classroom—one alderman jokingly swears she used to paddle him—but she’s more of a softie than her soldier boss. Working from her airless cubicle at city hall for 18 months, she says she tried to keep the town on course, even started a Yard of the Month beautification program, but admits she didn’t push and yell like the mayor.

At the school district too, the war created holes that had to be filled and that began to feel like a contagion. First, grade-school librarian Nolan Brown, a grandfather, Vietnam vet and National Guardsman, was called up for a desk job in Baghdad. Math teacher Kathy Mannon stepped into his post. Eleven days later, her husband Dennis, the librarian at the high school, was called up by the Air Force Reserve. Retired teacher Judy Gray, nearing 60, volunteered to fill in for him. Gray’s own daughter Regina Jones had just seen her husband Albert leave for Iraq too. Jones, an elementary-school teacher, says the call-up was a strain on the town’s children, since most knew someone going off to war. “With them all being National Guard” rather than active military, she says, “it was even more of a shock.”

The wives struggled. Farrah Chambliss, pregnant with the police chief’s first child, moved in with her mother even as she continued working as a sales rep for a uniform company. Angela Bunn, the mayor’s wife, found herself with four kids at home, trying to juggle her regular substitute-teaching job with her husband’s insulation business. Handling mold complaints while worrying about his living or dying was tough. “I was taking Paxil and Prozac,” she says. “People said, ‘You’re handling this well,’ and I’d say, ‘That’s the purpose of the medicine.’ But I still worried. I would have panic attacks at night, not in front of the kids. I’d go sit in the closet and cry.”

Now that the mayor and the police chief are back, life in Bradford is settling into old patterns. The short-order cook at McCall’s forgot the mayor’s lunch order on Bunn’s first day back. The men of the “round table,” who gather to gossip every morning and night at Edens Quick Check, are talking trucking, not war or politics. Back in the safe cocoon of Bradford, the police chief is having regrets about re-upping in the Guard, especially since his daughter took her first step. “I believe in God and country and making a sacrifice without crying about it,” says Chambliss. “If I had to go back, I would. But I feel like a guy should only have to go once.”

The mayor, meanwhile, is not due to get out of the Guard until 2009. He has been ordered by his doctors to relax-not that he often succeeds. He finished his first day back at work by personally bushhogging the dense brush on a lot belonging to the town. He issued 46 condemnation notices against residents—six against one alderman—for having junk in their yards last week. His wife reports with a smile that he sometimes forgets where he is and barks, “Do what I say, when I say, how I say” at home too. She just ignores him—one sign, anyway, that life is trying to return to normal in Bradford, Ark.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Finding The Way Home

US Military Finds Itself in Twilight Zone

On the day that U.S. citizens honored the nation’s war dead, the U.S. armed forces found themselves in a twilight zone somewhere between glory and hell.

On the one hand, the U.S. soldier has rarely ridden as high in terms of public image; no politician of stature — neither Democrat nor Republican, neither conservative nor liberal — dares to say anything negative about the conduct or integrity of those in uniform.

Even anti-war forces affirm their admiration for the professional military, blaming scandals such as torture and detainee abuse at Abu Ghraib prison and elsewhere on civilian bosses.

The military has become ”the apotheosis of all that is great and good about contemporary America,” writes Boston University professor Andrew Bacevich, a retired army colonel, in his new book, ‘The American Military: How Americans Are Seduced by War.’

On the other hand, the Army and Marines find themselves in the middle of by far their worst recruitment crisis since the military draft was ended in the waning days of the Vietnam War — so bad, in fact, that recruiters who have been told to lower basic eligibility requirements and offer unprecedented financial and other inducements for young men and women to join are still unable to fill their quotas.

”Army recruiting is in a death spiral,” retired Army Lt. Col. Charles Krohn, who was forced out of the service for publicly noting the severity of the problem as an Army spokesman, recently told right-wing Washington Post columnist Robert Novak, while his former boss, the top Army recruitment officer, told the New York Times that no relief was in sight.

On the one hand, Pentagon chief Donald Rumsfeld and his chief ”transformation” advisers could not be more excited about the new opportunities for Washington to sustain its full-spectrum military dominance through space-warfare inventions, such as lasers and ”rods from gods” that will hurl death-dealing metal from the heavens at more than 100,000 kilometers per hour onto precise, geo-orbitally located targets far below.

On the other hand, more than two years after conquering Iraq, an occupation force of 140,000 U.S. soldiers and Marines still are unable to secure the highway that runs between the Green Zone, the center of the Iraqi government in Baghdad, and the city’s airport just 10 kilometers away against guerrilla attacks and their increasingly sophisticated improvised explosive devices.

Thirty years after its ignominious withdrawal from Vietnam, senior military officers find themselves at a kind of mid-point between their dreams of glory — achieved with stunning speed in their lightning-like, two-week dash to Baghdad in 2003 — and nagging nightmares of ultimate defeat, be it in the form of the war of attrition that kills 15 or 20 of their troops each week, or in the outbreak of a full-scale civil war in Iraq that would make their continued presence untenable.

The war of attrition is damaging enough, according to the latest polls which show a steady drop, since a brief resurgence four months ago in the wake of the January 30 Iraq elections, in public approval both for the original decision to go to war and in President George W. Bush’s handling of the war. The latter has now fallen to an all-time low of just 37 percent.

That was translated into a little-noticed vote on Capitol Hill last week that must have given the historically sensitive military officers an unhappy sense of déjà vu: With just a couple of hours’ notice, supporters of a resolution that called for Bush to submit a plan as soon as practicable to withdraw all U.S. troops from Iraq gathered 128 votes.

The resolution was voted down 300-128, as expected. But a solid majority of Democratic lawmakers and five Republicans, including one of the party’s most highly respected foreign-affairs experts, Iowa Representative James Leach, showed unexpected support for what Bush administration stalwarts would call a ”cut-and-run” strategy. Four months ago, a letter calling for such a plan gathered the support of only 24 Democrats.

Most senior officers recognize that Bush’s adventure in Iraq has put the military in a precarious state. Not only have retired officers, such as the former commander of the U.S. Central Command, Maj. Gen. Anthony Zinni, been the most outspoken critics of the war, but even serving officers have voiced subtle and sometimes not-so-subtle warnings about both the prospects for success in Iraq and the implications of being tied down there indefinitely.

The chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Air Force Gen. Richard Myers, warned a year ago that ”there is no way to militarily lose in Iraq” and coupled that assertion with the observation that there is also now way to win militarily in Iraq. That synopsis evoked painful memories from Vietnam veterans who note bitterly that the U.S. lost the war despite the fact that its troops never lost a single battle.

It was also Myers, long criticized by his colleagues for not standing up to Pentagon chief Donald Rumsfeld, who told Congress last month in a classified report leaked to media that the current concentration of U.S. troops and equipment in Iraq and Afghanistan limits the ability of his forces to deal with other conflicts speedily and effectively.

That also was the message a year ago from Gen. John Riggs, a highly decorated Vietnam veteran who was in charge of the Army’s modernization program until he was forced to resign shortly after he voiced his concerns to the Baltimore Sun. His previous boss, Army Chief of Staff Gen. Eric Shinseki, also was unceremoniously retired early after he warned Congress that several hundred thousand U.S. troops would be needed to occupy Iraq.

Both men clashed publicly with Rumsfeld’s notions of military ”transformation” in which the speed and lethality of the U.S. armed forces have been given a much higher priority than more mundane and labor-intensive matters like the skills and equipment needed to maintain law and order or fight insurgencies. The former may be good for conventional wars but for unconventional conflicts, such as Vietnam 30 years ago or Iraq today, technology has its limits.

The fact that they were punished for their views has sent a strong message to the top brass who, like Myers and his successor-designate, Marine Gen. Peter Pace, have accordingly avoided challenging the civilian leadership on military questions, just as their predecessors did during the Vietnam years.

To the great frustration of the middle ranks, repeated assertions by Bush and Rumsfeld that the military leadership has told them they have enough troops in Iraq are probably true. ”The military part of (the defense secretary’s office) has been politicized,” Gen. Jay Garner, the Pentagon’s original choice to run Iraq, told the Sun. ”If (officers) disagree, they are ostracized and their reputations are ruined.”

Thus, a cowed and politicized military establishment, hailed as invincible just two years ago, marches steadily on a demoralizing but all-too-familiar path.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Tagged | Comments Off on US Military Finds Itself in Twilight Zone

Depleted Uranium Bill Introduced into Congress

Congressman Jim McDermott (D-WA), a medical doctor, on May 17 introduced legislation with 21 original co-sponsors in the House of Representatives that calls for medical and scientific studies on the health and environmental impacts from the U.S. Military’s use of depleted uranium (DU) munitions in combat zones, including Iraq. The McDermott bill also calls for cleanup and mitigation of sites in the U.S. contaminated by DU.

    “The need is urgent and imperative for full, fair and impartial studies,” McDermott said. “We may be endangering the health and lives of U.S. soldiers and Iraqi civilians. All we’ve gotten so far from the Pentagon are assurances. We need facts backed by science. We don’t have that today.”

    Because of its density, the military uses DU as a protective shield around tanks, and in munitions like armor piercing bullets and tank shells. DU tends to spontaneously ignite upon impact, disintegrating into a micro-fine residue that hangs suspended in the air where it can be inhaled and falls to the ground to leach into the soil.

    DU is a by-product of the uranium enrichment process; it is chemically toxic. and DU has low-level radioactivity. About 300 metric tons of DU munitions were fired during the first Gulf War, and about half that amount has been used to date in the Iraq War.

    “I’ve been concerned about DU since veterans of the first Gulf War began to experience unexplained illnesses, commonly called ‘Gulf War Syndrome’ that remain mysterious,” McDermott said.

    McDermott added that there are reports from Iraqi doctors and others today of seemingly unexplained serious illnesses including higher rates of cancer and leukemia, and even birth defects.

    “We pretended there was no problem with Agent Orange after Vietnam and later the Pentagon recanted, after untold suffering by veterans. I want to know scientifically if DU poses serious dangers to our soldiers and Iraqi civilians.”

    The Depleted Uranium Munitions Study Act of 2005 has 21 original co-sponsors, all Democrats, including: Reps. Charles Rangel, Pete Stark, Sherrod Brown, Peter DeFazio, Maurice Hinchey, Raul Grijalva, Jan Schakowsky, Robert Wexler, Sam Farr, Tammy Baldwin, Robert Andrews, Bob Filner, Jay Inslee, Jose Serrano, Lynn Woolsey, Earl Blumenauer, Bart Stupak, Mike Honda, Tom Udall, Barney Frank and Ed Markey.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Depleted Uranium Bill Introduced into Congress

Iraq War: Drafting the dead

Iraq War: Drafting the dead

President Bush was among the 260,000 graves at Arlington National Cemetery when he said it. But it was clear Monday that the president was referring to the more than 1,650 Americans killed to date in Iraq when he said, “We must honor them by completing the mission for which they gave their lives; by defeating the terrorists.”

Bush insists on clinging to the thoroughly discredited notion that there was any connection between the old Iraqi regime — no matter how lawless and brutal — and the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

U.S. military action against an Afghan regime that harbored al-Qaida was a legitimate response to the 9/11 attacks. The invasion of Iraq was not.

As of Memorial Day 2003, Bush had declared major combat operations at an end, predicted that weapons of mass destruction would be found and that U.S. forces were in the process of stabilizing Iraq. One hundred sixty U.S. troops had died.

The U.S. death toll has grown more than tenfold. No weapons of mass destruction were found. More than 700 Iraqis have been killed since Iraq’s new government was formed April 28.

Bush said of the insurgents at a news conference yesterday, “I believe the Iraqi government is plenty capable of dealing with them.”

Of course, this is the same president that assured the world that military intervention in Iraq was a last resort and that the United States would make every effort to avoid war through diplomacy. Giving lie to that as well is the so-called Downing Street War Memo, which shows that as early as July 2002, “Bush wanted to remove Saddam, through military action, justified by the conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the Intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy.”

Perhaps all presidents’ remarks in military graveyards are by nature self-serving. But few have been so callow as the president’s using the deaths of U.S. troops in his unjustified war as justification for its continuance.

SEATTLEPI.COM POLLIs it time to begin the careful but quick withdrawal of American forces from Iraq? 92.1{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d}
Yes, the death toll for Americans and Iraqis alike continues to grow, with no obvious plan to defeat the insurgency. We’ve broken it and we can’t fix it. 7.9{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d}
No, we must stay the course or else the terrorists will have won.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Iraq War: Drafting the dead

They Also Serve Who Stand for Peace

On Memorial Day, we honor people who have gone to perilous places with a strong commitment in their hearts. They risk danger and their own death because they feel passionate about a cause.

My dad, born in 1920, was the right age to fight in World War II, but he didn’t go because he had a bum heart, a result of childhood rheumatic fever. My father-in-law, born in 1919, didn’t go either. He was excused because his heart was too good – he was a conscientious objector. He spent the war doing “alternative service” in the states, jumping out of airplanes to fight forest fires in the West.

I would never argue that those who fight and to die for our country aren’t heroes. I think very often they are. I know I’m not capable of making that level of sacrifice, and I also know I have personally benefited from the work of those who are. I am one of the legion in our country who take time on Memorial Day to consider the sacrifices that have been made by people who have fought and died to keep us safe and free.

But on Memorial Day I also honor those who work to end war – or to avert it. Our diverse country is big enough for many kinds of heroes, including people who work for peace.

My father-in-law, Hubert, quietly told his draft board that he didn’t want to kill anyone and he stood bravely to face the tough consequences. When he tells me about it now, the memories are softened by the 63 years since his decision. The passion he must have felt has given way to a quiet humor. A man who reveres music, the dramatic arts and literature, he tells me that he just wasn’t cut out to kill. He adds, “I’m also not good at marching in rows.”

I know it was the killing that kept him home from the war, not the marching.

Guys just as sweet, just as peace-loving and artsy as Hubert made the other decision, the decision to go and fight for their country. Looking back from 2005, Hubert says that the men who went to war and those who didn’t got along fine. In his college crowd there was no shame in becoming a conscientious objector.

I ask Hubert about his brothers who served in the military, the people in his town, and in the broader society – what did they say about his opting out of the war. He says only that some people were angry and some were OK, adding that introspective people, “people who worked things out in their minds were more accepting.”

I honor the people who have fought righteous battles to keep me free and I also honor my father-in-law who risked his life to keep from taking another. That act of courage, of sanity, added value to my world. Those who cling to their own peaceful hearts amid pressure to do violence are heroes.

I honor Marla Ruzicka, a Californian. Bright-eyed. Blonde. Beautiful. Selfless. The day after Saddam’s statue came down, Marla, then 25 years old, went door-to-door in Iraq, checking on the people, trying to determine how many innocent Iraqis the United States had mistakenly killed.

Armed only with a college degree, a charming personality and a piercing intellect, Marla hosted parties in the middle of wars. In Baghdad and Bagram, in Mosul and Kabul, she invited military advisers, aid workers, journalists and locals to come together and socialize. Using her refreshingly unorthodox means, this young woman managed to get language into a Senate appropriations bill that has ultimately provided $7.5 million in U.S. assistance to the civilians we have accidentally injured, and displaced in Afghanistan and survivors of those killed – and $10 million more for those in Iraq.

When interviewed by Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post, she said, “It is a luxury for people to say war is bad . . . You can’t say something is bad unless you come in with ways to fix it.”

Like Hubert, who worked like a dog jumping from airplanes into forest fires to make his patriotic contribution, Marla didn’t take the easy way out, she didn’t stay home.

Marla died last month, giving her life in this damned Iraq war. She and Faiz Ali Salim, her Iraqi friend and colleague, were killed by a suicide bomber attacking nearby U.S. troops. Phillip Robertson of Salon.com reported, “When the bomber detonated his explosives, Marla and Faiz were among those killed, and with that terrible act, the bomber cut short the life of a tireless champion of the victims of the war.”

Ironies pile up as high as the dead during wartime.

Like our brave American military veterans, Marla, and Hubert 60 years before her, went to perilous places with a strong commitment in their hearts. They risked danger and death because they felt passionate about a cause.

That cause is peace.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on They Also Serve Who Stand for Peace

Mom of Slain GI Denied Gold Star Status

Friday, May 27, 2005

WHITE PLAINS, N.Y. – Everyone agrees that Ligaya Lagman (search) is a Gold Star mother, part of the long line of mournful women whose sons or daughters gave their lives for their country. Her 27-year-old son, Army Staff Sgt.

Anthony Lagman (search), was killed last year in Afghanistan, but American Gold Star Mothers Inc., has rejected Lagman, a Filipino, for membership because – though a permanent resident and a taxpayer – she is not a U.S.

citizen.

“There’s nothing we can do because that’s what our organization says: You have to be an American citizen,” national President Ann Herd said Thursday.

“We can’t go changing the rules every time the wind blows.”

That explanation isn’t satisfying the war veterans who sponsored Lagman’s application, some other members of the mothers’ group or several members of Congress.

“It is disheartening that any mother of a soldier, sailor, airman or Marine who has died in the line of duty would be denied membership in an organization that honors the memory of fallen service men and women,” said Rep. Nita Lowey (search), whose district includes Lagman’s home in Yonkers.

Rep. Eliot Engel, who represents an adjoining district, said the group should change its rules immediately.

“Whatever the excuse, American Gold Star Mothers’ decision smacks of xenophobia and is in stark contrast to what Mrs. Lagman’s son fought and died for,” Engel said.

Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (search) said, “We now have many noncitizens serving honorably in our armed services, and I hope that this can be satisfactorily resolved.”

A past president of the mothers’ group, Dorothy Oxendine, of Farmingdale, said, “There’s no discrimination in a national cemetery. There’s no discrimination when they get killed side by side. So how can we discriminate against a mother?”

Another past president, Ann Wolcott, of York, Pa., said, “Times have changed since this organization was started, and there are a lot of men and women serving today whose parents are not citizens. I think they deserve every honor and privilege that we have as Gold Star mothers.”

Oxendine and Wolcott said they believe that given the increasing diversity of the armed forces there have been noncitizens in the 1,200-member organization who overlooked or ignored the citizenship question on the application.

Lagman has lived in the United States for more than 20 years. She was not at home Thursday, apparently tending to her husband, who is hospitalized. But her other son, Chris Lagman, said in Thursday’s The Journal News that all she wants “is recognition as the mother of this fallen soldier.”

Lagman’s application was initiated by Ben Spadaro (search), a veteran from Yonkers, who said he learned about the citizenship rules of the American Gold Star Mothers (search) while working on a national cemetery committee of the Veterans Administration. When he learned of Anthony Lagman’s death and saw Lagman was a citizen but his mother was not, he thought, “He’s buried in a military cemetery, with full honors. She should be able to join.”

“We decided to tell the absolute truth on the application,” he said. “We put down, `I am not an American citizen.’ It was a ploy to get them to reject her, and then we said they should change the rules.”

But the organization’s 12-member executive board voted against any change.

“We can’t go changing the rules every time we turn around,” said Herd, the national president. “When we have problems within our organization with people not abiding by the rules, we just get it straightened out, we don’t change the rules.”

Oxendine, the former president, said she is sure the general membership would approve a rules change if the board did.

“I can’t believe that 12 intelligent women would ever not have it in their hearts to think about another Gold Star mother,” Oxendine said. “You pay a high price to join the American Gold Star Mothers. I figure her dues were paid.”

Spadaro isn’t giving up. He had his brother, a Florida lawyer, write to the Department of Justice, noting the mothers’ organization has received federal assistance and demanding an investigation.

And on Monday, during Memorial Day observances at Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 2285 in Eastchester, Lagman will be presented with a gold necklace bearing a simple gold star.

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Mom of Slain GI Denied Gold Star Status

Iraqi president expects Saddam trial in 2 months

BAGHDAD (Reuters) – Saddam Hussein could go on trial for crimes against humanity within two months, far earlier than expected, Iraq’s new president, Jalal Talabani, said on Tuesday.

Asked in an interview televised on CNN when Saddam’s trial would begin, Talabani said: “I hope within two months.”

Iraqi prosecutors and their U.S. advisers say a trial is more likely in 2006, after some of Saddam’s lieutenants have been tried, to help build the case against the former dictator.

Iraqi leaders hope that trials of Saddam and his aides will help restore public confidence, sapped by relentless insurgent violence and political bickering that delayed the formation of a cabinet for months.

In Washington, President Bush said that despite mounting casualties in Iraq, “I’m pleased with the progress” being made.

“I am pleased that … there is a democratically elected government in Iraq, there are thousands of Iraqi soldiers trained and better equipped to fight for their own country,” he told a news conference in the White House Rose Garden.

More than 1,600 Americans have been killed since Saddam was ousted in April 2003, 70 of them in May alone. But Bush expressed confidence the Iraqi government would get the situation under control, enabling U.S. troops to pull out.

“And when they’re ready, we’ll come home. And I hope that’s sooner rather than later.”

In the latest losses for U.S.-led forces in Iraq, four Italians, four Americans and an Iraqi were killed in two aircraft crashes, officials said.

A six-seater Iraqi Air Force plane crashed 150 km (90 miles) northeast of Baghdad on Monday, killing four U.S. Air Force personnel and an Iraqi pilot, Iraq’s Defense Ministry said.

A ministry spokesman said he believed the plane came down in a sandstorm. The U.S. military said it was investigating.

Overnight, an Italian military helicopter crashed outside the southern city of Nassiriya as it returned from Kuwait, killing the two pilots and two gunners. The cause of the crash was unknown, but it was believed to be non-hostile.

JAAFARI CONDEMNS ARREST OF SUNNI

In Baghdad, Prime Minister Ibrahim Jaafari condemned the arrest by U.S. troops on Monday of senior Sunni politician Mohsen Abdul-Hamid, leader of the Iraqi Islamic Party.

He said he had demanded an explanation from the top American general in Iraq for the 12-hour detention, which the military has said was a mistake.

Relatives of Abdul-Hamid said U.S. troops broke down the door of his family home, ransacked the house and put a hood over his head before carting him and his three sons away.

The arrest threatened to put further strain on relations between Iraq’s Sunni Arab and Shi’ite communities at a time when some have expressed fears of a slide toward civil war.

In his speech to parliament, Jaafari said he hoped a new constitution, due to be drafted by mid-August, would be drawn up on time, but admitted it was a tight deadline. He said improving security, his biggest headache, was a formidable task.

“There are big problems, we don’t claim that we’ll remove all obstacles, but we’ll make a tangible difference in security and public services,” he said.

On Sunday his government launched Operation Lightning, aiming to put 40,000 Iraqi police and soldiers on the streets of Baghdad to hit back at insurgents.

Jaafari said the operation had so far resulted in a large number of arrests of Iraqi and foreign militants and the discovery of several car bomb workshops.

Car bombs are perhaps Iraq’s biggest threat. In May, 140 explosives-laden vehicles detonated across the country, a huge rise from 2004 monthly figures.

Al Qaeda’s network in Iraq, headed by Jordanian militant Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, has claimed responsibility for many of the attacks.

Zarqawi sent a message to al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden saying he had suffered only “minor wounds,” denying reports he was seriously hurt, according to an audio tape attributed to him and released on the Internet on Monday.

“I think news has reached your ears … that I was seriously wounded … I would like to assure you and assure Muslims that these are baseless rumors and that my wounds are minor,” said the speaker.

ZARQAWI IN “GOOD HEALTH”

“I am now with the help of God enjoying good health among my brothers and my people in Iraq.” The voice sounded like that of Zarqawi — Washington’s number one enemy in Iraq with a $25 million bounty on his head.

In fresh violence on Tuesday, a truck bomb exploded near an Iraqi military checkpoint in Baquba, killing two soldiers and wounding nine, police and doctors said.

In western Iraq’s violent Anbar province, the kidnapped provincial governor Raja Nawaf was found dead along with his militant captors after a clash with U.S. forces, a government spokesman said.

(Additional reporting by Omar Anwar and Mussab al-Khairalla in Baghdad)

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Comments Off on Iraqi president expects Saddam trial in 2 months

For the Wounded, No Miracle Is Small

BETHESDA, Md. — The Ryan family stood vigil, gathered around a hospital bed in Building 10, Ward Five East — a surgical ward at the National Naval Medical Center. Before them lay Marine Cpl. Eddie Ryan, silent and pale, a grievous bullet wound in his brain and a feeding tube in his belly, straight through the “N” in a blue tattoo that spelled “RYAN.”

Angela Ryan stroked her son’s fine hair. Christopher Ryan squeezed his boy’s hand. Felicia Ryan, 19, looked into her brother’s eyes, her hand on a Bible resting against his left leg.

The news was not good.

Eddie’s neurosurgeon, Robert Rosenbaum, had told the family that the young Marine’s frontal lobes had been terribly damaged by a bullet that tore into his skull during a firefight in western Iraq on April 13. It was quite possible that Eddie, 21, would never fully regain consciousness or recover what the doctor called “full cognitive activity.”

Christopher stared at his son’s smooth face and spoke: “We need a miracle. Eddie’s going to be our miracle Marine. We’re praying that God gives us this miracle because my son is a great American.”

Across the hall the same day this month, Marine Cpl. Bryan Trusty sat up in bed, wolfing down a chicken dinner on a hospital tray. His father, Steve, sat at his bedside, amazed that his son was eating and talking, and even laughing.

On April 3, a hot shard of shrapnel ripped a hole beneath Bryan’s left eye, pierced the length of his brain and lodged against his brain stem. He survived emergency surgery in Baghdad, but went into cardiac arrest on the medevac flight to the U.S. on April 7. His doctors did not expect him to live.

Now Bryan, who turned 21 in the intensive care unit four weeks earlier, was about to be discharged for outpatient therapy, with shrapnel still in his brain and his arm, and a distinct memory of all that had befallen him. He is able to walk and speak normally.

“I call him my miracle child,” his father said, watching him eat.

The number of service members wounded in Iraq has surged past 12,000, half of them injured so badly that they cannot return to duty. Many of the most critical cases end up here at the National Naval Medical Center, established in the early days of World War II.

On the worst nights at the Bethesda hospital complex, ambulances and casualty buses deliver up to 100 wounded Marines and sailors from Iraq. Since the invasion of Iraq in March 2003, more than 1,700 have arrived, most of them young and suffering from the devastating damage inflicted on human tissue by explosives, bullets and shrapnel.

Some, like Bryan Trusty, stay only a few weeks. Others, like Eddie Ryan, stay longer. The soldiers are surrounded by attentive nurses and skilled surgeons, and by loved ones who cling to hope and share an ordeal that can be both traumatic and uplifting, their lives in turmoil and forever altered.

If not for Eddie’s tattoos, Angela Ryan would not have recognized her son after she and her husband flew to see him at a military hospital in Germany. His face and body were grotesquely swollen. Before he was wounded, Eddie was lean and fit, 6 feet tall and 195 pounds. He had ballooned to 250 pounds because of severe swelling and fluid accumulation caused by injuries.

Eddie is a sniper, one of the Marine Corps’ elite. He signed up straight out of high school and was sent to Iraq. He was on his second tour there when an enemy bullet pierced his brain.

Since he arrived here last month, his mother has not left his side. She sleeps in his room or down the hall in the visitors’ lounge. His father and sister have left the hospital once, to drive Eddie’s beloved black Toyota Tacoma pickup from a friend’s house in Virginia to the family home in Ellenville, N.Y.

The Ryans have taken leaves from their jobs — Christopher, 43, as a heavy equipment operator and Angela, 46, as a school lunchroom monitor. Felicia has left community college and a job at an outdoor supply store.

“Wherever Eddie is, that’s our life now,” Felicia said.

The Bible resting on the hospital bed contained a photo of Eddie in his Marine dress uniform, looking handsome and fearless. Placed between his feet were an embroidered Marine Corps logo and a photo of Eddie and his family the day they picked him up at Camp Lejeune, N.C., when he returned safely from his first tour in Iraq.

Much of the time, Eddie’s eyes were open. He breathed on his own, but he did not speak. He was shirtless, and his tattoos were on display. His parents had not approved of them; for a while, Eddie wore long-sleeved shirts to hide them. But now the Ryans found comfort and inspiration in the body markings.

On Eddie’s abdomen is the RYAN tattoo. On his right arm is a tattoo of hands in prayer and the Marine Corps logo. On his left arm is an American flag and the words “Land of the free because of the brave.”

His parents read to him from the Bible, squeezing his hands as they prayed. His father read him a favorite passage, Psalm 50, Verse 15: “And call upon me in the day of trouble. I will deliver thee and thou shall glorify me…. “

“Eddie’s faith is very important to him,” Angela said, careful, as always, to speak of her son in the present tense.

In the evenings, she sang to him. He loved being sung to at night as a boy, she said, and often he would fall asleep to “Jesus Loves Me, This I Know.” She sang him the hymn, softly.

Sometimes Angela sang a favorite song titled “Show Me Your Ways,” which includes the lines, “Show me your ways that I may talk with you … to live with the touch of your hand, stronger each day, show me the way.”

“That’s my prayer,” she said, “to walk with him and talk with him again.”

Rosenbaum, the neurosurgeon, was candid with the Ryans about their son’s prospects: “From the beginning, I made it very clear to Eddie’s mom and dad that if we were successful in keeping him alive after the initial swelling, they’d be taking home a human form, but I did not think they’d be able to take home Eddie as they remembered him. He will not remember his dog or his best friend or his room at home. If a miracle of miracles happens and he wakes up and begins to interact, they’ll have a person they’ve never met before.

“And, unfortunately, that is the extreme best scenario.”

The bullet or bullet fragments that penetrated Eddie’s brain created a percussive wave that produced a temporary cavity and caused severe bilateral frontal lobe injuries, Rosenbaum said. Portions of his skull were destroyed on impact; others were removed by surgeons in Iraq to relieve brain swelling.

“The doctor told us that Eddie lost two-thirds of his frontal lobes,” Christopher said. “And the frontal lobes are what makes Eddie, Eddie.”

However, Rosenbaum said, Eddie’s youth and superb physical condition can improve his degree of recovery. He’s a fitness fanatic and an amateur boxer. On home leave, he would jog in his combat boots, lugging a backpack loaded with rocks.

Twice a day, Rosenbaum checked Eddie for a response to a stimulus — a pinch, the squeeze of a hand. He said this month that he had not detected anything more than purely reflexive responses, but he promised the Ryans that he would devote “200{cd9ac3671b356cd86fdb96f1eda7eb3bb1367f54cff58cc36abbd73c33c82e1d} effort” to their son.

“Not only Eddie, but Eddie’s parents have made the sacrifices that the country asked of them,” Rosenbaum said. “It’s the responsibility of those of us here to do our very best for them.”

In Eddie’s room, Felicia tried gently to get her brother to arm wrestle; they roughhoused often as kids.

“I was holding his hand down and I was like: Come on, let’s arm wrestle — and he pushed my hand down,” she said. “So I pushed back and I was like: Are you going to let me win? And he pushed my hand back down. That’s Eddie — he’s very competitive.”

Every day, Felicia held family snapshots in front of Eddie, and his eyes seemed to fix on them. She pointed out friends and relatives, describing the circumstances behind each image.

The family showed Eddie cards and letters from the hundreds sent by friends and strangers. Packages of fruit, flowers and food arrived daily from the Ryans’ relatives, co-workers and church members. The family heard that their hometown plans to dedicate this weekend’s Memorial Day parade to Cpl. Edward Joseph Ryan II.

Marines dropped by regularly, most of whom had never met Eddie but wanted to show solidarity. Marine commanders have visited, along with retired Marine snipers. They were upbeat and encouraging.

“It’s important that these boys see a positive attitude,” Angela said of her son and the two dozen other wounded Marines on the ward. “We need to give them hope. If you’re over their bed crying all the time, they’ll know you’re doing badly.

“Eddie always told me: ‘Don’t worry about me, Mom, I’ll be OK.’ “

In his room, Bryan Trusty was up and walking, preparing to go home. His doctors had anticipated a stay of several months, but he was being discharged after a few weeks.

“You should have seen this boy,” his father said. “He looked like he’d been shot in the face with a shotgun. He went into cardiac arrest on the plane ride home. He had no brain waves. Now look at him.”

Bryan shrugged and smiled. Slender and fair-haired, he speaks with a slight Midwestern twang. He said he remembered little of the plane flight, but every detail of the firefight in which he was wounded. It happened during an insurgent attack on Abu Ghraib prison, when he rushed to a guard tower to help fellow Marines.

A rocket-propelled grenade exploded inside the tower, injuring Bryan and five other Marines. In all, 44 Americans were wounded during the battle.

“I didn’t see the RPG come in, but I saw it explode,” Bryan said. “I caught a piece of shrapnel in the frontal lobe and another piece went back to the brain stem.” His right arm was broken.

A Navy corpsman, Benjamin Graves, dragged him to safety, Bryan said. Graves suffered severe wounds and ended up down the hall at Bethesda, where he and Bryan were reunited with another Marine injured in the tower.

“When Graves got discharged, his mother told us: ‘Trusty, it’s time for you to get up out of bed and get out of here too,’ ” Steve Trusty said.

There is a long red scar on Bryan’s scalp from surgery in Baghdad to remove shrapnel, and a tiny spot beneath his left eye where the shrapnel penetrated, shattering his spectacles. Surgeons decided to leave the shrapnel lodged against his brain stem because of the risk involved in removing it.

Bryan’s swift recovery is highly unusual, “just an absolute tremendous turnaround,” said James R. Dunne, the first surgeon to treat him when he arrived at Bethesda.

There is no single reason, he said. “Just the luck of the draw, really. It depends on the path of the fragment, the extent of the damage — a lot of factors.

“But these young guys have very plastic brains and can overcome some really serious injuries,” Dunne said.

Bryan felt strong enough on Mother’s Day to take his mother, Deborah Hall, to dinner at a restaurant. The following week, he was sent to a Veterans Affairs hospital in Louisville, Ky., near the family home in Corydon, Ind., for therapy to help improve his short-term memory. He wants to return to school to study computer science. He built his first computer as a high school sophomore.

Bryan and Eddie joined the Marines in response to the Sept. 11 attacks and were based at Camp Lejeune, but they had never met. Even so, before Bryan left the hospital, he sought out Christopher Ryan.

“I told him to just be patient, Eddie will get better,” he said. “I said it may look bad right now, but they need to keep the faith and everything will be OK.”

Bryan’s mother told Angela: “We’ve seen amazing things happen here, and so can you.”

In Eddie’s room, Christopher looked down at his son, who seemed to gaze back. “Look into his face and you’ll see he’s a good boy who helps people,” the father said. “He’s a selfless person. He was more concerned about his country and his fellow Marines and his family than he was about himself.

“He knew he was fighting for us here at home. Fighting is what got Eddie in here, and fighting is what’s going to get him out.”

“That — and prayer,” Angela said.

As they monitored Eddie’s vital signs, the nurses fussed over him and spoke gently to him. The food tube gurgled and Eddie coughed. His mother and his father held his shoulders to comfort him, and another quiet afternoon passed as the Ryan family awaited a miracle.

Last week, they got it — or at least an early installment. Eddie was stable enough to be transferred to a VA hospital in Richmond, Va., for rehabilitation therapy.

He is now able to move his hands and to hold up two fingers on command, his father said Thursday night. He no longer needs a feeding tube, and he recognizes friends and family members. He is alert and responsive. He has smiled for the first time since he was wounded.

Four days ago, Christopher said, his son managed to speak his first word: “Mom.”

Posted in Veterans for Common Sense News | Tagged | Comments Off on For the Wounded, No Miracle Is Small